Home / Resources / Obsolete parts
Modernization

Your contractor says the parts are obsolete. Is it true?

The obsolescence letter is one of the most effective sales documents in the elevator industry. Sometimes it is exactly right. Often it is a timeline the contractor would prefer, presented as a timeline the equipment requires. The difference is worth verifying before the board votes.

What "obsolete" can mean

The word covers several very different situations, and letters rarely say which one applies:

  • Discontinued by the manufacturer. The original manufacturer no longer makes the part. That alone does not make the equipment unsupportable. Many components remain available through independent suppliers, rebuilders, and repair services.
  • Unsupported by this contractor. The maintaining company has chosen not to stock or repair the part. That is a business decision about their service, not a fact about your equipment.
  • Genuinely unavailable. No reasonable source exists, and a failure would leave the unit down for an extended period. This is real, and it deserves a plan.
  • Code driven. A condition or component no longer meets requirements that apply to your building and must be addressed. This is also real, and the scope is often narrower than a full modernization.

Questions to put to the letter

  • Which specific components are obsolete, by model or part description, on which units?
  • Has any of those components actually failed, and how long did the repair take?
  • Is the claim that the part is unavailable from anyone, or that this contractor does not supply it?
  • What does the maintenance agreement say about obsolescence? Many contain a clause that lets the contractor exclude coverage once it declares equipment obsolete.
  • Is a targeted replacement of the affected component, such as a door operator or a controller, a realistic alternative to a full modernization?

What the board should do

Treat the letter as the start of a decision, not the decision. An independent condition assessment establishes which components are truly at end of life, which are supportable, and what a reasonable timeline looks like. Sometimes the honest answer is that modernization should happen soon, and the board can then plan it properly with a competitive, non proprietary scope. Often the answer is that targeted repairs and proper maintenance buy several years, which lets the association fund the project through reserves instead of a special assessment.

Either outcome is better than signing on the contractor's schedule because nobody checked.

The standing offer. Send your maintenance contract, a recent invoice, or a modernization quote to andrew@oceanviewelevator.com. Within five business days you get a written, plain language read on what it says, what it costs you, and what to do about it. No charge. No obligation. No sales pitch, because we have nothing to sell you.

Related reading

Send the paperwork. Get a straight answer.

A maintenance contract, an invoice that looks off, or a modernization quote. Email it over and within five business days you get a written, plain language read from an independent QEI certified consultant. No charge, no obligation, and no pitch at the end.

Start a No Charge Document Review
Send a Document for Review Email